Pakistan Faces Internet Slowdown Amid Controversy Over Possible Firewall
Pakistan has been grappling with painfully slow internet speeds for weeks, sparking a heated debate over the cause. Activists accuse the government of constructing a China-style internet firewall to tighten control over the online space, while officials attribute the problem to the widespread use of virtual private networks (VPNs), which they claim are straining the network.
The issue has become a focal point of contention following widespread unrest triggered by former Prime Minister Imran Khan last year. During the ensuing turmoil, the government imposed blocks on social media platforms and throttled internet speeds, as the battle for public support extended from the streets to the digital realm. Since February, the micro-blogging platform X (formerly Twitter) has been inaccessible in Pakistan due to purported “national security” concerns. Imran Khan’s supporters are significant users of X, and Khan himself is the most followed Pakistani on the platform, with nearly 21 million followers.
On Sunday, Minister of State for Information Technology Shaza Fatima refuted claims that the government is responsible for the recent slowdown. Fatima stated that her team has been “working tirelessly” with internet service providers and telecommunications companies to address the issue. She attributed the slow speeds to a high volume of VPN usage, which she claimed was putting excessive strain on the network. According to Fatima, allegations that the government is behind the slow connections are “completely false.” She did, however, confirm that the government is upgrading its systems to enhance cybersecurity, emphasizing that such measures are necessary due to ongoing cyber threats.
Activists have criticized Fatima’s response as a “political dodge.” Shahzad Ahmad, director of the digital rights organization Bytes for All, told the BBC that his organization has “ample tech evidence” of a state-imposed firewall. Ahmad suggested that the firewall’s purpose is to monitor online traffic and suppress political expression, arguing that it affects not only civil liberties but also economic livelihoods. Farieha Aziz, co-founder of the non-profit Bolo Bhi, highlighted the detrimental impact on Pakistan’s business sector. The Pakistan Software Houses Association warned that the slowdown could jeopardize the country’s business prospects, estimating potential losses of up to $300 million and describing the situation as a “direct, tangible, and aggressive assault” on the IT industry’s viability.
In response to the crisis, activists have petitioned the Islamabad High Court, seeking to have access to the internet recognized as a fundamental right under Pakistan’s constitution.
Technology
UK Considers Social Media Ban for Under-16s Amid Safety Concerns
The UK government is exploring a potential ban on social media for under-16s, according to Technology Secretary Peter Kyle. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Kyle emphasized that safeguarding children online is a top priority, stating he would “do what it takes” to ensure their safety.
Kyle also announced plans for further research into the effects of technology, including social media and smartphones, on young people. He noted the lack of “firm, peer-reviewed evidence” on the matter and said such data would inform future decisions.
Online Safety Act Enforcement
The announcement coincides with Kyle’s “letter of strategic intent” to Ofcom, the UK’s communications regulator, which will soon gain new enforcement powers under the Online Safety Act (OSA). The OSA, set to take effect in 2024, requires tech companies to take greater responsibility for the content on their platforms, particularly to shield children from harmful material.
Kyle stressed the importance of assertive regulation, calling on Ofcom to fully utilize its authority under the Act. “I just want to make sure that Ofcom knows that government expects them to be used,” he said.
Under the OSA, social media and messaging platforms face steep fines—potentially in the billions—if they fail to comply. Some platforms have already introduced changes, such as Instagram’s new teen accounts and Roblox’s ban on young children messaging others.
Calls for Broader Action
The Molly Rose Foundation, a campaign group advocating for online safety, welcomed Kyle’s efforts but urged the government to strengthen the OSA. “The public and parents back an updated Act that embeds an overarching duty of care on tech firms,” the group posted on social media platform X, calling for swift action from the Prime Minister.
Legal experts have cautioned that banning social media for young people is only part of the solution. Iona Silverman, a lawyer at Freeths, described the measure as “a drop in an ocean-sized problem,” pointing out that teenagers may still find ways to access harmful content. She called for a broader cultural shift and more proactive legislation to address the issue.
Lessons from Australia
The UK’s deliberations come after Australia announced plans to ban social media for children under 16. When asked if the UK would adopt a similar policy, Kyle said, “Everything is on the table,” but stressed the need for evidence-based decisions.
Smartphone Use Under Scrutiny
The debate extends beyond social media to smartphone usage among young people. Parliament is reviewing a private member’s bill addressing digital safety for children, with input from the Healthcare Professionals for Safer Screens group. Founder and GP Rebecca Foljambe highlighted growing concerns among health professionals about smartphone overuse.
While the government has stopped short of banning smartphones in schools, it has issued guidelines to promote effective restrictions. Kyle previously stated that the “battle over phone use in schools had been won.”
Critics, however, continue to call for more decisive action to protect children in an increasingly digital world.
Technology
Autonomous Vehicles Face Hurdles in Gaining Public Trust, Despite Rapid Growth
Technology
Electric Flying Taxis Face Turbulence Amid Financial and Technical Challenges
-
Travel7 months ago
Embracing Solo Travel to Unlock Opportunities for Adventure and Growth
-
Education8 months ago
Exlplore the Top Universities in the United States for Computer Science Education?
-
Politics8 months ago
Six Best Things Done by Donald Trump as President
-
Technology7 months ago
Revolutionizing Healthcare Training with Latest Technologies
-
Health7 months ago
Rise of Liposuction: A Minimally Invasive Solution for Body Contouring
-
Business8 months ago
Thriving Startup Hubs: Best Cities in the USA for Entrepreneurship
-
Travel7 months ago
Where to Move? America’s Top Ten Most Affordable Cities
-
Health7 months ago
Digestive Power of taking Mint Tea after Meals